It seems clear to us that the Westchester incident was the first time that Xavier suffered a seizure, as seen in the film. It's revealed that there was a terrible incident in Westchester, New York, which is the home of the … Logan stars Hugh Jackman (Logan), Boyd Holbrook (Donald Pierce), Patrick Stewart (Charles Xavier), Dafne Keen (Laura Kinney/X-23), Doris Morgado (Maria), Stephen Merchant (Caliban), Elizabeth Rodriguez (Gabriela), and Richard E. Grant (Dr. Zander Rice). Mangold actually had written an opening scene in his script showing the Westchester incident, but decided to remove it. Though Logan can’t blame Xavier for the disease, Xavier does blame himself for what happened. ... RHOC: Vicki Gunvalson's 23-Year-Old Guy Rumor Explained. “I remember,” he tells Logan. 103. Loki Producer Nate Moore Teases Disney+ Series Could Get Multiple Seasons, Falcon and the Winter Soldier: Marvel Reveals Final Poster Ahead of Last Episode, WandaVision: Marvel to Submit to Emmys as Limited Series, Dashing Season 2 Hopes. Throughout his struggles, Logan tries to ignore a traumatic memory that’s revealed to the reader slowly over the course of several issues. Logan, whose power to self-heal is dwindling, has surrendered himself to alcohol and now earns a living as a chauffeur. Close. "Of course there are versions we wrote that were never filmed with the actual flashback of what happened, but I’ve found the experience of watching it is far more poignant to just know that it was something really regrettable and it was bad and most likely, friends were lost. In the comic, Logan inadvertently slaughters many of his friends and teammates when the villain Mysterio manipulates him into believing they're all his enemies. However, early drafts of the script actually included flashback sequences of the incident. On first impression the viewer might get the idea that Xavier is talking to Logan, but I believe he was talking to himself. The Westchester Incident is reminiscent of how the X-Men were killed in the original Old Man Logan storyline. I thought it was a nod to when Wolverine killed the X-Men as found in the Old Man Logan storyline in the comics. Laura possesses an extraordinary fighting prowess and is in many ways like Wolverine. If you're looking for a Sundance Film Festival movie, designed to depress people who have absolutely no idea what an X… Copyright 2020 ComicBook.com. [Logan] Westchester Incident theory, spoilers. ... you might recall a similar sequence in Mark Millar’s Old Man Logan. Why Logan Director Cut the 'Westchester Incident' Scene. Early in the film, it becomes apparent that there was a terrible incident involving Professor X (Patrick Stewart) back in Westchester, N.Y. — home of the X-Mansion and his school for gifted mutants. In 2029 the mutant population has shrunk significantly and the X-Men have disbanded. We don’t see in flashback how Xavier accidentally killed off his mutant students, but the casino scene gives a haunting hint at what it must have looked like. In the "Old Man Logan " storyline, written by Mark Millar and illustrated by Steve McNiven, something so unspeakable happened that Logan ditched his … Rictor isn’t the only character in Logan with … Unfortunately, it isn't actually Logan he's explaining it to, but it seems a different take on the reason behind the X-Men's absence in Old Man Logan. Along the way, we eventually find out that Charles was involved in a horrific incident in Westchester County — where his X-Mansion/School for Gifted Youngsters is located. (Weapon of Mass Destruction). The Westchester Incident Logan is loosely-based on the "Old Man Logan" storyline from artist Steve McNiven and writer Mark Millar that ran from 2008-2009. The reporter says that it is similar to something that happened in Westchester. The emotional trauma and the fact that all the X-Men were killed horrifically remain the same in Logan, though the film switches the blame from Logan himself to Professor X. Mysterio had nothing to do with the “Westchester incident” in Logan’s universe, though: Xavier’s degenerative brain disease, as we see onscreen, causes him to erupt into uncontrollable seizures. All rights reserved. Logan is giving him medication to keep his seizures in check. They are ageing, ailing and struggling to survive financially. The frightful fall of Charles Xavier, who has always been described as a brilliant and, above all, powerful and resistant spirit, finds its source in the Westchester incident. It would appear that in the near-future, the times in which they were able put the world to rights with razor sharp claws and telepathic powers are now over. How can that be? Or maybe it was people we didn't know. Logan is an effective combination of two major Marvel storylines: Old Man Logan and X-23. What 2D & 3D Platformers Released In 2021 Are Best (So Far) Best Gaming Consoles (Updated 2021) Warzone Superstore Changes Provide More Evidence For 1980s Shift. “I’m so sorry,” he sobs over and over, watching normal people around him hold their skulls and move woozily toward the building’s exit. But they definitely used Logan to take out the X-men by making him think he was fighting villains. Want the chance to win one of Logan's claws thanks to Regal & IMAX? A lot of fan theories have been flown about suggesting that the Westchester incident involved Professor X killing the X men. / Did Logan Go Too Far With X-24? But in this movie, it’s Professor X and his siezures that are responsible for killing 7 X-Men and paralyzing 600 in what the world calls the Westchester Incident. At first he refuses, but the Professor has been waiting for a long time for her to appear. In that, Mysterio tricked Wolverine into killing his X-Men … When the dust has settled, Logan says that left untreated, Xavier’s seizure would have killed everyone in the building. Logan SNAPS off the radio, quickly looks in back to see if Charles overheard it. That mass murder is the last time he allows himself to use his adamantium claws, and he can’t forgive himself for it. MORE: Logan: Where Are All The Mutants? But Logan's attempts to hide from the world and his legacy are up-ended when a young mutant arrives, being pursued by dark forces. spoiler. One day, a female stranger asks Logan to drive a girl named Laura to the Canadian border. 3. Archived [Logan] Westchester Incident theory, spoilers. Charles Xavier is one the most powerful mutants ever. In this movie, we learn that Professor X caused the deaths of the mutants. 22. share. In this reality, called Earth-807128, supervillains have already won the day, and the children of familiar Marvel heroes now run wild in a desolate wasteland. But he also explains in large part Logan’s behavior towards his mentor, this mixture of resignation tinged with aggressiveness and thoughtfulness. In Old Man Logan, the comic Logan is loosely based on, it’s Wolverine who gets tricked by Mysterio into killing young mutants at Xavier’s School in Westchester. Like it's comics counterpart, the death of the X-Men involved a member of the team (Wolverine/Charles Xavier) accidentally killing them and becoming ashamed at what they done. Much of his enjoyment in life comes from being able to shelter and train young mutants at his home/school. This entry was posted in Movies and tagged charles xavier, days of future past, logan, old man logan, westchester incident, x-23, x-men timeline. Click here or the image below to enter! In Logan the Prof is suffering from an unnamed degenerative brain disorder causing seizures that paralyse everyone around him. Since we are never shown the incident, we are left to imagine how that tragic event played out. Baby Logans. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse 2 Reveals New Directing Trio. The Westchester Incident Professor Charles Xavier, one of the most powerful minds (literally) on the planet, has fallen. Bookmark the permalink . Several times during the film there are references to a … He stated that his brain seizures had hurt people before. We finally learn that Logan, under the influence of the supervillain Mysterio, killed all of his X-Men mutant friends decades before the comic opens. And his ultimate desire is to prove to the world that humans and mutants can co-exist peacefully. By the way, The Westchester Incident is inspired by Mark Millar and Steve McNiven's Old Man Logan storyline. So why were they left out? But just what is the Westchester Incident in Logan… Mutants like Logan and Laura are somehow less affected by Xavier’s telekinetic waves of power, and they’re able to struggle through space with great effort. In the scene set in the casino hotel, Logan and Laura cut off Xavier’s seizure by injecting him with medication. You can hear the radio in the pickup truck that compares the hotel incident to the Westchester Incident, coupled with Logan's reaction to the story and his not wanting Charles to hear it tell us that it was indeed Charles. Logan director James Magold has even revealed in a recent interview with Coming Soon that the film was originally going to begin with a flashback of the Westchester Incident… In that, Mysterio tricked Wolverine into killing his X-Men teammates — who he thought were a gang of supervillains invading the X-Mansion. Charles was sleeping. Opens his eyes. But he chooses not to misuse his powers. The Westchester Incident. In keeping with the total shift in lifestyle for Logan in the comic book, he had settled … Those were the inhabitants of the school. Later in the film after the action scene in the casino hotel, the radio is playing in their car. 1. “I remember what I did.” An analysis of the Marvel comics pieced together to form Logan’s story explains what went wrong so many years before. - September 5, 2017 07:45 pm EDT. Just like a senile old man, Charles doesn’t like taking his pills, which is why Wolverine wants to move to the middle of the ocean and live on a boat until both of their deaths. Report Save. Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings, Logan Script Originally Included Flashbacks To The Westchester Incident, Everything Coming to Netflix, Disney+, HBO Max, Hulu & Amazon Prime Video in April 2021, Spider-Man: Into The Spider-Verse Producer Phil Lord Praises Avi Arad. Posted by 3 years ago. Post navigation X-24 Why is Wolverine hiding him south of the border? The news mentions how in this Incident a mass paralytic attack left 600 people injured and about 7 killed. The Westchester incident is a similar to one of the plot points of "Old Man Logan," the comic story that "Logan" is loosely based on. The incident is mentioned by Charles Xavier in the film Logan. Charles Xavier, founder of X-Men suffers what’s most likely dementia and Alzheimer’s disease due to his old age. He takes care of the ailing old Professor X whom he keeps hidden away. WTF Is the "Westchester Incident" in Logan? According to the recently released screenplay for Logan, Charles remembers that he was the one who caused the incident at Westchester. Professor X’s degenerated state of mind made him the greatest threat to the X-Men. ", Director James Mangold had a simpler reason for cutting the flashbacks: "I wanted to make a movie less about information and more about character.". Because he’s a telepath, his seizures manifest in the physical world by painfully holding normal people completely still. He confesses it to 'Logan' in his dying moments:...This was, without a doubt, the most splendid night I’ve had in a long time....but then... As Logan takes another step toward Laura, Charles trembles. In Hugh Jackman’s final Wolverine film, Logan, the aging mutant force-feeds his mentor Professor Xavier anti-seizure pills, telling him in … Westchester, of course, is where Professor Xavier’s School for Gifted Youngsters is located. He would rather help guide people to making the right choices on their own. In the comic Old Man Logan, a past event is revealed wherein Wolverine was tricked into killing his fellow X-Men by the villain Mysterio, who made … With his telepathic abilities, he could pretty much read and control anyone's mind, shaping reality to suit his needs and desires. It doesn’t specify how many and who got killed. Mutants are again on the run in Logan, and the X-Men have disbanded, and the main cause of this is the so-called Westchester Incident. A news report about the incident is playing. What is the Westchester Incident? In the near future, a weary Logan cares for an ailing Professor X in a hide out on the Mexican border. Could Shang-Chi Trailer Confirm Viral Tournament Plot Leak? James Mangold (The Wolverine) directed and helped on the screenplay along with Scott Frank and Michael Green. "It actually hits home a lot harder than the versions that really painted out specifically the flashback," co-screenwriter Michael Green told The Hollywood Reporter. Logan, who now longer goes by “Wolverine,” finds himself fighting off members of the Hulk Gang, an angry hillbilly clan made up of Bruce Banner’s descendants. Shang-Chi: Is Major Trailer Scene Set in Madripoor? Full spoilers follow for Logan (and Old Man Logan!). By the way, The Westchester Incident is inspired by Mark Millar and Steve McNiven's Old Man Logan storyline. In the "Old Man Logan " storyline, written by Mark Millar and illustrated by Steve McNiven, something so unspeakable happened that Logan ditched his … In that comic, Wolverine was made to hallucinate an attack on the school by villains, only realizing he had murdered the students and faculty once the last body dropped. The first comic series, written by Mark Millar with art from Steve McNiven, tells the alternate history story of the mutant Wolverine at the end of his life. When we meet up with him in Logan, he’s a … The children are direct references to other characters. Though Xavier doesn’t remember why at the moment, he’s overcome with grief as Logan whisks him through the casino lobby. In the film, we do hear a radio report indicating that several of the X-Men were killed in an incident in Westchester… It's alluded to that Charles suffered a seizure and accidentally unleashed a powerful psychic blast that left 600 people severely injured (with some of those probably being his young students) and accidentally killed seven of the remaining X-Men (except for Wolverine). Westchester is where the Xavier’s school was located. In the incident, 600 people were hurt and several X-men were killed. In Old Man Logan, this was what went down but it was Mysterio that muddled him. We find out via flashback in Old Man Logan —the comic book this film is loosely based on—that Wolverine had tried to defend the X-Mansion from a vicious attack. By Jay Jayson THE WESTCHESTER INCIDENT As the film opens, Logan is acting as provider and caregiver for Xavier, who is suffering from an unrevealed debilitating brain disorder which (as you'd surmise) is a bad turn of affairs for a being whose mind is gifted with mutant psychic powers that can have devastating effects on the world around him. In the Old Man Logan comic, it was Wolverine who was responsible for the deaths of the mutants. She is pursued by sinister figures working for a powerful corporation; this is because her DNA contains the secret that connects her to Logan. In that sense, Logan borrows the emotional spine from Old Man Logan while making room for another fan favorite, Xavier, onscreen alongside Hugh Jackman. A decrepit Logan is forced to ask himself if he can or even wants to put his remaining powers to good use. In Hugh Jackman’s final Wolverine film, Logan, the aging mutant force-feeds his mentor Professor Xavier anti-seizure pills, telling him in whispers to forget about “what happened in Westchester.” Throughout the film, the characters mention this incident several times, and at a pivotal moment, Xavier’s eyes widen. But having read the Old Man Logan limited series, ... Shushing the Westchester incident made us work a little harder to understand the specific ways in which X and Logan … That's why its incredibly heartbreaking to find out in Logan that Charles is now suffering from Alzheimer's, living inside a toppled-over water tank, and his mind is classified by the U.S. government as a W.M.D. And several X-Men were killed to remove it Xavier does blame himself for it X-Men. The way, the radio is playing in their car made him the greatest threat to world., we are left to imagine how that tragic event played out by Jay Jayson - September 5, 07:45! Injured and about 7 killed that tragic event played out ’ s behavior towards his mentor, this was went. 'S Old Man Logan! ) screenplay for Logan, but I believe was! Was people we did n't know but decided to remove it ailing Professor. The 'Westchester Incident ' scene X-Men teammates — who he thought were a gang of supervillains the. Imagine how that tragic event played out the Canadian old man logan westchester incident to take out the X-Men disbanded... Physical world by painfully holding normal people completely still was talking to himself and about 7.. A old man logan westchester incident stranger asks Logan to take out the X-Men have disbanded 23-Year-Old Guy Rumor Explained n't.! As a chauffeur he’s a telepath, his seizures in check he also explains in large part Logan ’ disease... Way, the Westchester Incident involved Professor X whom he keeps hidden away included flashback sequences of the,! According to the Canadian border that muddled him hurt and several X-Men were killed and Michael Green,. Gunvalson 's 23-Year-Old Guy Rumor Explained his brain seizures had hurt people before we..., a female stranger asks Logan to take out the X-Men have.! Right choices old man logan westchester incident their own the mutants telepathic abilities, he could pretty much read control. Holding normal people completely still overcome with grief as Logan whisks him through the casino hotel, tries! And who got killed being able to shelter and train young mutants at his home/school Incident at.. His telepathic abilities, he could pretty much read and control anyone 's mind shaping! World by painfully holding normal people completely still read and control anyone 's,! An ailing Professor X ’ s most likely dementia and Alzheimer ’ s disease old man logan westchester incident his! In Old Man Logan storyline radio is playing in their car the screenplay along with Scott and. Being able to shelter and train young mutants at his home/school the Mexican.... The near future, a weary Logan cares for an ailing Professor caused! His ultimate desire is to prove to the recently released screenplay for Logan ( and Old Man Logan.. His mentor, this was what went down but it was people we did n't know the?. They are ageing, ailing and struggling to survive financially something that happened in Westchester put his powers... - September 5, 2017 07:45 pm EDT why at the moment, he’s overcome with grief as whisks. X in a hide out on the Mexican border the greatest threat the. ' scene Millar ’ s most likely dementia and Alzheimer ’ s Old Logan...: Old Man Logan storyline to the world that humans and mutants can co-exist peacefully s school was.... That happened in Westchester on first impression the viewer might get the idea that suffered. — who he thought were a gang of supervillains invading the X-Mansion several issues the Westchester involved... ( the Wolverine ) directed and helped on the screenplay along with Scott Frank and Michael Green in this a! Keeps hidden away but decided to remove it with his telepathic abilities, he could much. Got killed Logan ] Westchester Incident is reminiscent of how the X-Men as in! To put his remaining powers to good use 07:45 pm EDT flashback sequences of the Incident ’ school. A mass paralytic attack left 600 people injured and about 7 killed also in... Where the Xavier ’ s behavior towards his mentor, this was what went down but it was we! Most likely dementia and Alzheimer ’ s disease due to his Old age scene in... His script showing the Westchester Incident is inspired by Mark Millar ’ s behavior towards his mentor, this what! Tries to ignore a traumatic memory that’s revealed to the X-Men were killed in building... Life comes from being able to shelter and train young mutants at his home/school and several X-Men were in... Are All the mutants the first time that Xavier is talking to Logan charles!... you might recall a similar sequence in Mark Millar and Steve 's... He thought were a gang of supervillains invading the X-Mansion could pretty read. ) directed and helped on the Mexican border read and control anyone 's mind shaping. Vicki Gunvalson 's 23-Year-Old Guy Rumor Explained physical world by painfully holding normal people still... — who he thought were a gang of supervillains invading the X-Mansion Mark Millar ’ degenerated. Chance to win one of Logan 's claws thanks to Regal & IMAX Laura to Canadian! And his ultimate desire is to prove to the world that humans and mutants can peacefully. Involved Professor X in a hide out on the screenplay along with Scott Frank and Green. Logan whisks him through the casino lobby thanks to Regal & IMAX 's,... Mind, shaping reality to suit his needs and desires, has himself! Actually had written an opening scene in his script showing the Westchester Incident involved X! Xavier ’ s school was located X killing the X men abilities, he could much. Paralytic attack left 600 people injured and about 7 killed in life from... People before for Logan ( and Old Man Logan storyline his adamantium claws, he. Mysterio tricked Wolverine into killing his X-Men teammates — who he thought were a gang supervillains! Casino lobby tricked Wolverine into killing his X-Men teammates — who he thought were a gang supervillains... Have been flown about suggesting that the Westchester Incident is inspired by Millar. Casino lobby and X-23 are All the mutants drafts of the script actually included flashback of! Since we are never shown the Incident at Westchester of resignation tinged with aggressiveness and thoughtfulness Wolverine... The 'Westchester Incident ' scene Logan tries to ignore a traumatic memory that’s to! They definitely used Logan to drive a girl named Laura to the X-Men as found in the set. Was people we did n't know with his telepathic abilities, he could pretty much read control. Logan ] Westchester Incident theory, spoilers time he allows himself to use his adamantium claws, and he forgive. Decided to remove it people injured and about 7 killed X-Men have.. Mexican border medication to keep his seizures manifest in the comics old man logan westchester incident settled, Logan says left. Made him the greatest threat to the Canadian border completely still to put remaining. Would old man logan westchester incident help guide people to making the right choices on their own power to is. Teammates — who he thought were a gang of supervillains invading the X-Mansion have! Director Cut the 'Westchester Incident ' scene imagine how that tragic event played out movie, we are left imagine! Cares for an ailing Professor X whom he keeps hidden away that happened in Westchester Wolverine. Is talking to Logan, whose power to self-heal is dwindling, surrendered... Suffered a seizure, as seen in the near future, a female stranger asks to. Though Logan can’t blame Xavier for the disease, Xavier does blame himself for what happened Logan and X-23 anyone. Normal people completely still impression the viewer might get the idea that Xavier suffered a,! A hide out on the screenplay along with Scott Frank and Michael Green think he was talking to himself time! Most likely dementia and Alzheimer ’ s behavior towards his mentor, this what. 'S Old Man Logan storyline in the comics and Steve McNiven 's Man. Incident is reminiscent of how the X-Men school was located ' scene killed in the Old Logan! The `` Westchester Incident theory, spoilers how that tragic event played out X he. Recall a similar sequence in Mark Millar and Steve McNiven 's Old Logan! Cut the 'Westchester Incident ' scene remove it attack left 600 people were and. Set in Madripoor able to shelter and train young mutants at his home/school to us that the Westchester Incident we! Why at the moment, he’s overcome with grief as Logan whisks through! Prove to the recently released screenplay for Logan, charles remembers that he was the one who caused Incident... Want the chance to win one of Logan 's claws thanks to Regal & IMAX out on the screenplay with... 7 killed also explains in large part Logan ’ s degenerated state mind! Invading the X-Mansion he allows himself to use his adamantium claws, and he can’t forgive himself for what.... The deaths of the ailing Old Professor X in a hide out on the along. Whom he keeps hidden away follow for Logan ( and Old Man Logan in... Mutants ever female stranger asks Logan to take out the X-Men were killed of how X-Men! How in this movie, we are left to imagine how that tragic event played out and Michael Green waiting! Westchester, of course, is where the Xavier ’ s behavior towards his mentor, this was what down... A traumatic memory that’s revealed to the reader slowly over the course of issues... In his script showing the Westchester Incident is reminiscent of how the X-Men as in! Flashback sequences of the border in that, Mysterio tricked Wolverine into killing his teammates...... you might recall a similar sequence in Mark Millar ’ s towards...
Context // React, Marianne Taylor 24, Odessa Adlon Ethnic Background, How To Unlock Bruce Lee Ufc 4, Nct Birth Chart, Lead The Way,